TripAdvisor.com: Do Their Business Listings Have Any SEO Value?

Trip Advisor logoWe have several hotel and resort clients here at Screen Pilot which allows our SEO team to consistently explore new ways to gain coveted Google back-links as well as back-links in the other main search engines like Yahoo and Bing. The primary goal for the hotel and resort industry, when talking about the internet, is to sell rooms and generate great online reputation in social and other user generated content (UGC) media. This led to the creation of many “review” sites. In the travel vertical, TripAdvisor.com is one of the pivotal players in this space. Online travel agencies (OTAs) like Orbitz have integrated proprietary user reviews into their site and vertical search players like Kayak, have integrated 3rd party reviews from service like Epinions and others. Trip Advisor’s key consumer proposition is creating consumer-facing content that other travelers deem relevant to their shopping process. Users can post reviews, rate certain aspects of a property and even share their vacation pictures. In an attempt to generate additional revenues and capitalize on their traffic volumes, Trip Adivsor, in a move away from their traditional business model, have created what’s called a Business Listing.  These listings would include a link to the hotel or resort website.  So, the SEO team here at Screen Pilot decided to have a closer look at the  TripAdvisor.comBusiness Listing‘ option and to see if there really is any SEO value from having a business listing with them.

To begin the experiment we looked at numerous New York City hotels, that all have business listings on TripAdvisor.com, with a hyper-linked URL to their website. Next we looked up the back-links in Google and Yahoo for all of the properties. Surprisingly, none of them showed any back-links from TripAdvisor.com. On one of the properties we profiled, the Library Hotel, we did find a back-link from Trip Advisor, but it was coming from the French version of the site.  It also was part of a review that someone had embedded a link. As we could not find any back-links from TripAdvisor.com for these properties, we then went back to the Trip Advisor business listing itself and found the real issue.

Once we pulled the TripAdvisor.com business listing source code, we noticed that the actual link is not physically there but rather JavaScript code instead. This script is generating the link and its anchor text on the page. When the search engine spiders visit a page with a Business Listing on it, this script is not allowing the link to be indexed which would normally show up as a backlink from TripAdvisor.com. So, as a business owner, you are still getting the traffic from people clicking on the link in your listing, but from an SEO standpoint you are not getting the “link juice” from the TripAdvisor.coms’ 8/10 page rank!

Some might ask the question “Why not just drop the link in a review on TripAdvisor.com and that will suffice?” Well, on TripAdvisor.com you can’t do that. Unlike the French version of the website, the .com version does not allow reviewers to put hyperlinks within their reviews.

So the moral of the story is this, be sure you know the full SEO benefit you are getting from purchasing a listing on any social travel related website, especially TripAdvisor.com if that is something you think you’re getting. In their defense, we find nothing on their site that remotely even leads anyone to believe that there is SEO value in a Business Listing, it simply is assumed that because they are offering a “link” to your property website, there is inherent link value associated with it.

If you’re a hotel or resort owner and you want to talk to us about SEO for your property, please get in touch. We have tons of experience in amazingly successful hotel internet marketing & SEO campaigns and we are a full-service digital marketing agency.

  • http://www.cottages.co.uk Jon

    Hi Tom

    Nice piece.

  • http://hotelitour.com Claude

    Your are right

    Since the begining (10 years now), TripAdvisor have a no follow technical stuff and strategy for is backlinks.

    The amazing stuff , it’s that 99 % of hotels are not aware about it

    Best regards from Marseille

    Claude

  • http://www.hiddenworlds.com Hidden Worlds

    That is lame that Trip Advisor is no-follow. I can understand for the comments, maybe (even though I don’t agree), but for the actual listings that is absurd.

  • http://www.innkeepingblog.com Jay Karen

    You fail to mention the possible reason TripAdvisor has made these Business Listing links “no follow” links…they too compete in SEO with the thousands of properties on their site. Giving “link juice” to their properties would possibly conflict with their own SEO strategy. Google the name of just about any property, and you’ll find their TripAdvisor review page up there on page 1 of Googlee right along with the property’s own web site. They don’t want to aide and abet the competition by giving them “link juice.” And the TripAdvisor badges and review widgets used by many properties provide many links back to TripAdvisor, thereby giving TripAdvisor more SEO love for the very key words that the properties try leveraging.

    They are an internet marketing company competing in a highly-competitive marketplace. It’s hard to knock them for trying to keep a leg up.

    I told them at their office a couple of weeks ago that if they removed the no-follow code, they could earn a lot of good will and possibly even more customers. But I do understand the nature of the conflict of interest in doing so. We’ll see. There are some pretty smart cookies over in Newton, MA.

  • http://tripadvisorwatch.wordpress.com/ Phil At TripAdvisorWatch

    It doesn’t surprise me, but it was remiss of me not to have thought of exposing this myself – thanks for doing the work for me!

    I also suspect that many owners who put TA widgets on their sites don’t realise that they are giving TA a keyword-rich link at the same time :
    http://tripadvisorwatch.wordpress.com/2010/04/12/tripadvisor-widgets/

    All one-way traffic!

    Phil

  • marghe

    Is it not true that paying for and selling links is against Google guidelines and can negatively impact a site’s ranking in search results?
    To me, it seems obvious that the link has a “nofollow” tag…
    what do you think?

  • nadia hardie

    Thanks for this info. Found it really helpful considering we were exploring the issue of whether to pay for a business listing or not for this very reason. Cheers!

  • http://www.beaurive.com Neelante

    My technical knowledge is very limited but all I can tell you is that in 6 months of having a business listing on Tripadvisor we have not received one direct, linked enquiry as a result. (And we are the #1 hotel in their popularity listing for our country).

  • http://www.screenpilot.com TomD

    Yes, but in this case you would not technically be paying for such a link. It would be considered a value add of the commercial transaction and hence open to interpretation and discussions between TA and Google.

  • http://www.screenpilot.com TomD

    Hi Phil,

    Yes, TA were quick to realize that a perceived “hey look at our reviews on TA” would be a hit with a lot of the hospitality world that weren’t ‘boxes’ and of course the inbound links that all these sites then gave them helped push TA in the early days. To some degree indeed still do based on normal algorithmic assumptions.

  • http://www.screenpilot.com TomD

    Must admit, as a firm that deals with online direct distribution for our clients, we whole hardheartedly agree. For what at the time they are charging for said listings, it’s crazy not to think that they might give a bit away!